Platforms with White-Label Merchants (e.g., Pinduoduo):

• Merchant Entry:Lower entry thresholds require stricter supervision.
• Applicability:Common for low-priced, non-standard goods where return costs exceed product value.
• Refund Process:Fast and simple for low-cost items, often automatic. Higher-priced items may involve partial refunds or credit-based assessments.
• Focus:Effective for inexpensive, non-standard products.

Platforms with Brand Merchants (e.g., JD.com):

• Merchant Quality:High-quality brands reduce the need for frequent refunds.
• Applicability:Rarely used for high-priced, standardized items like premium electronics.
• Refund Process:Slower, involving user-merchant agreements and platform reviews for higher-priced goods.

This rule enhances consumer trust on white-label platforms but is less common on brand-focused platforms with higher service standards.

3.2 REFUND RULES ONLY – RULE PROFILE (4/4)

The impact of refund rules on all parties in the platform ecosystem

Positive Aspects:

• Lower Trial and Error Costs: Helps consumers get quick refunds when products don’t meet expectations, avoiding disputes and improving the shopping experience.
• Better Merchant Structure: Eliminates low-quality merchants, improving the overall merchant ecosystem.
• Encourages Quality: Motivates merchants, especially white-label sellers, to improve quality control and maintain higher standards.
• Efficient After-Sales Service: Reduces the need for lengthy customer service processes, providing faster refunds and boosting consumer trust and loyalty.

Negative Aspects:

• Loss of Consumer Trust: Overuse of the policy for poor-quality products can frustrate consumers and reduce their confidence in the platform.
• Higher Costs for SMBs: Small and medium businesses face increased costs, especially from rule abuse or high return rates (e.g., in clothing).
• Platform Ecosystem Risks: Malicious use of the policy by some consumers can hurt the platform, leading to lower product quality and higher return rates, harming long-term growth.